Traveller hiking along a mountain path





The professional indemnity market for financial advisers in the UK: A decade of change and the path ahead

The professional indemnity insurance (PII) landscape for financial advisers in the UK has experienced significant shifts from 2014 to the present, shaped by regulatory changes, market dynamics, and notably, the introduction of pension freedoms.

Read on for an overview of the past, current, and future state of this critical market, shedding light on the challenges and opportunities that have emerged, including the impact of increased Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) limits.

Past: 2014-2022, a period of adjustment

The period between 2014 and 2022 was marked by significant regulatory changes and evolving market conditions.

The introduction of pension freedoms in 2015 stands out as a landmark reform, granting individuals aged 55 and older greater access to their pension savings. While this offered unprecedented flexibility to consumers, it also introduced complex advisory challenges and heightened risks for financial advisers. This, in turn, lead to increased scrutiny from insurers.

The aftermath of pension freedoms saw a surge in demand for advice on pension withdrawals and investments. This was accompanied by a corresponding increase in the complexity and liability associated with such advice.

The period also witnessed a crucial regulatory adjustment with the increase in Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) compensation limits in 2019. Since consumers could now claim higher amounts for misadvice, this change increased the potential liability for financial advisers, impacting the cost and terms of PII cover.

Insurers responded with caution, tightening underwriting criteria and raising premiums to mitigate the heightened risk exposure.

This era also saw some insurers exit the market, further straining capacity and complicating the quest for adequate and affordable PII cover for financial advisers.

Present: 2022-2024, navigating through stability and strain

From 2022 to 2024, the professional indemnity market for financial advisers has been navigating a phase of cautious stability, tempered by ongoing challenges.

The effects of pension freedoms continue to reverberate, with a steady flow of claims related to pension advice underscoring the need for stringent risk management and robust advice processes.

Despite these pressures, there are signs of market adaptation.

Insurers and financial advisers alike have developed a more nuanced understanding of the risks associated with pension freedoms and the increased FOS limits, leading to more sophisticated risk assessment and management practices.

Premiums, while still on the higher side, have begun to stabilise, reflecting a gradual balancing of risk perceptions with the realities of the advisory landscape.

The regulatory framework has also evolved, with the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) tightening standards around pension advice and PII requirements.

This regulatory push towards higher professional standards and better consumer protection is fostering a more resilient insurance market, albeit with the expectation that financial advisers maintain rigorous compliance and advisory protocols.

Future: Towards a new equilibrium

Looking forward, the professional indemnity market for financial advisers in the UK is poised to enter a phase of recalibration, as stakeholders continue to adapt to the long-term implications of pension freedoms, regulatory changes, and the impact of increased FOS compensation limits.

Technological advancements and insurtech innovations are expected to play a crucial role in shaping the future, offering more tailored and flexible insurance solutions that align with the specific needs and risk profiles of financial advisers.

The emphasis on continuous professional development, enhanced risk management strategies, and the adoption of technology in advisory processes will be pivotal in navigating the future landscape.

These elements are expected to contribute to a more stable and sustainable market, where the availability and affordability of PII cover reflect a balanced assessment of the risks and rewards inherent in providing financial advice.

In this evolving environment, the successful navigation of the professional indemnity market will require financial advisers to remain agile, informed, and proactive in their approaches to risk management and client service.

By doing so, they can secure their position in the market, ensuring their ability to provide valuable advice while managing the risks associated with pension freedoms, regulatory complexities, and the heightened liabilities introduced by increased FOS limits.

For those prepared to adapt and evolve, the future looks bright

While the professional indemnity insurance market for financial advisers has faced its share of challenges in the wake of pension freedoms, regulatory changes, and increased FOS compensation limits, the future holds promise for those prepared to adapt and evolve.

The journey from 2014 onwards has been a testament to the resilience and adaptability of the UK’s financial advisory sector, setting the stage for a future where the market not only recovers but thrives, underpinned by higher standards of professionalism and consumer protection.

Get in touch

This guest post was bought to you by Onyx – an independently owned Lloyd’s of London Insurance broker.

With more than 150 years’ experience, our clients benefit from the highest level of service and expert advice. If you’d like to find out more about how Onyx could help you, please contact Dan Kelly. Email, or call 020 3841 5571.  

Alternatively, speak to Tim or John at Jencap Partners and we’ll be happy to introduce you. Email, or call 029 2000 2325.